
“I've pulled a maple sapling out of a gutter in Scarborough. It had roots. Check yours before it starts a garden.”
— Tighty Whitey Samm Simon · renovation.reviewsIt's a slope game. Every run of trough is pitched about 1 inch for every 20 feet toward a downspout. Lose that pitch (sagging hangers, ice load, a ladder leaned in the wrong spot) and water sits in the trough instead of leaving. Sitting water rusts steel, breeds mosquitoes, and in winter it becomes an ice bar that pries the trough off the fascia. The system only counts if water ends up 6 feet away from your foundation. That last part is the whole point, and it's the part most homes get wrong.
Our freeze-thaw cycles are brutal. Meltwater refreezes in the trough overnight, expands, and works seams and hangers loose a little more every winter. Add mature-tree neighbourhoods (looking at you, Etobicoke and East York) where a single fall drops enough leaves to plug every downspout on the street. Most GTA houses also sit on clay, which swells when wet. So an overflowing gutter doesn't just stain siding, it feeds water straight into soil that pushes on your foundation.
Seamless means the trough for each run is rolled from a coil on site, in one piece, cut to your house. No seams except at corners means almost nowhere to leak. 5-inch is standard; 6-inch moves about 40% more water and makes sense under big or steep roofs. Thickness matters too: 0.027-gauge aluminum is the cheap stuff, 0.032 is what you want holding a ladder of ice. Ask what gauge you're being quoted. A low bid is usually thin metal and wide hanger spacing.
Old trough comes down before lunch. Fascia gets inspected, because putting new eavestrough on rotten wood is throwing money away, and this is when rot is cheap to fix. New runs are rolled in the driveway, hung with hidden hangers every 24 inches or less, pitched with a level, sealed at corners and outlets. Downspouts go in with extensions or splash pads. A good crew hoses the roof afterward and makes you watch where the water goes. One day, most houses.
Tick what checks out. Anything you can’t tick is worth a closer look.
Bad ones are. Cheap foam and brush inserts clog worse than open gutters. Good micro-mesh guards on a properly pitched trough keep ladders in the garage for years. On tree-heavy lots they pay for themselves; on a bare-lot bungalow you can skip them.
About half the overflow calls we get are actually pitch problems. The trough is clean but sagging, so water heads the wrong way and jumps the edge mid-run. If overflow happens away from the downspout, suspect slope, not leaves.
Dry summer weeks are the easiest install weather of the year, and winter ice damming is when eavestrough failure does its expensive damage. It's a year-round system. The maintenance is seasonal; the problems aren't.
| Spring | Clean out winter grit; check pitch after the thaw |
| Summer | Best install weather; dry days, easy access |
| Fall | Clean AFTER the leaves finish dropping, not before |
| Winter | Watch for icicles: that's heat loss plus poor drainage teaming up |